The Constitutionality of Sobriety Checkpoints
What are Sobriety Checkpoints?
Sobriety checkpoints are law enforcement initiated roadblocks which are usually set up on an anonymous road or highway in a community with a purpose of catching drunk drivers. Generally, the police will announce that a sobriety checkpoint will be conducted during a specific week or weekend, but will not disclose the location. An advance notice by a supervisory law enforcement official is required to be announced through the local media; however, the announcement of the precise location is not.
Many jurisdictions set up checkpoints late at night, during the holidays and on the weekends when they believe that the greatest number of drunk drivers will be on the roads (for example, Memorial Day, Independence Day and Labor Day weekends). In states that conduct sobriety checkpoints, each jurisdiction has its own way of conducting sobriety checks on drivers of motor vehicles.
But, every vehicle must be given an equal opportunity to being randomly checked. Some jurisdictions stop cars at predetermined intervals. For example, every 8th car that drives by will be stopped and the driver will be asked to take a breathalyzer test or a battery of mental and physical exercises to determine whether the driver is intoxicated. Other jurisdictions test every driver that passes the checkpoint with a fast breathalyzer test.
However, not all states conduct drunk driving checkpoints. Currently, there are eleven states which prohibit this practice and have made it illegal for the police to conduct sobriety checkpoints.
Which Constitutional Rights Are At Issue?
Under the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, it is “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, paper and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures”. Further, the Fourth Amendment states that this right “shall not be violated and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation. . . . ”
In the eleven states which have determined that drunk driving checkpoints intrude upon a person’s Fourth Amendment rights, it has been found that the checkpoints are a warrantless and supciousless search without probable cause.
Also, it has been argued that sobriety checkpoints creates a serious risk of an infringement upon a person‘s Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. Therefore, some states, such as Connecticut, have found that drivers do not have to answer questions such as, “Have you been drinking?” Because to force drivers to do so would violate their Fifth Amendment constitutional right against self incrimination.
Do Sobriety Checkpoints Violate the Driver’s Constitutional Rights?
Despite a minority of the states which do not have drunk driving roadblocks, the United States Supreme Court has found that the state interest in reducing drunk driving outweighs the minor infringement on a driver’s constitutional rights. Therefore, the Court
has found that sobriety checkpoints can be constitutional if they meet certain requirements.
In order for the checkpoints to be constitutional there must be clear guidelines that are carefully followed by the legal authorities. Additionally, the Court has left it up to each individual state to develop these guidelines. In California, for example, the state supreme court has held that the decisions about where to set up sobriety checkpoints and about which cars to stop (i.e. every car, every sixth car, etc) must be made by supervisors prior to officers setting up the checkpoints. The sites selected should be in areas that have a high incidence of drunk driving and the length of each stop should be minimized.
Nevertheless, the U.S. Supreme Court had dissenting opinions that disagree with the ruling that sobriety checkpoints can be constitutional.
Do You Have to Comply with Sobriety Checkpoints?
If the police ask you to stop your car at a sobriety checkpoint, or anywhere else, then you must comply. Similarly, a driver might not have to comply with a field sobriety test (FST). However, in Connecticut and other states, the driver would have to comply with the request to take a breathalyzer test since, by law, drivers licenses are conditioned upon drivers’ cooperation with taking a breathalyzer test when requested by law enforcement.
Drunk driving continues to be a serious public safety problem on America’s roads and highways. Sobriety checkpoints are meant to minimize the danger of drunk driving by catching people who commit this crime and by deterring others from driving while under the influence of alcohol. Therefore, it is important to know whether these types of checkpoints are legal in your state and what your rights are if you are stopped at a sobriety checkpoint.
For more information on sobriety checkpoints, contact a Drunk Driving Defense attorney today.
Additional Drunk Driving Defense Articles
The Crime of Drunk Driving
The definition of drunk driving is left up to each individual state. Each state decides the level at which a driver’s blood alcohol content is too high to … More
Defending a Drunk Driver Hit and Run Charge
Drivers who are charged with driving under the influence of alcohol face serious criminal charges. Most states impose significant fines and jail time on drunk … More
Possible Penalties for Drunk Driving
If you are found or plea guilty to the offense of drunk driving, there are a variety of possible penalties you will face. Since the offense of a drunk driving is … More
What is Aggravated DUI?
Some states have a more serious drunk driving charge often referred to as an aggravated DUI, also known as “extreme DUI” or “felony DUI”. It … More
What To Do If You're Arrested
It can be difficult to think clearly after an arrest. Many arrestees are scared about the social stigmas, personal consequences, financial consequences, legal … More
Overview of Drunk Driving Offenses in the United States
Each state in the country has passed a law which makes it illegal to drive a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Since this offense is … More
Drunk Driving Fourth Amendment Issues
How does the Fourth Amendment affect my drunk driving case? Under the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and under state constitutional provisions, a person … More
Do You Need An Attorney... or Can You Represent Yourself?
There are many circumstances in the United States when a person is entitled to represent himself in legal matters. The Supreme Court has found that the Sixth … More
Chemical Testing in Drunk Driving Cases
In driving while intoxicated or under the influence of alcohol or other intoxicants cases, such as drugs, law enforcement officials usually administer a series of … More
What to Bring to an Initial Consultation With a Lawyer
Beginning a legal action can be stressful, and most people considering hiring a lawyer are already in a stressful situation. You should do your best to prepare for … More