How Could O.J. Be Found Not Guilty In His Criminal Case, Yet, Liable In His Civil Case?

Home English FAQs Criminal Law Civil Versus Criminal Law

How Could O.J. Be Found Not Guilty In His Criminal Case, Yet, Liable In His Civil Case?

As discussed above, the burden of proof in a criminal matter is different than in a civil matter. To be found guilty in a criminal proceeding, the state must show beyond a reasonable doubt that you are guilty of the crime charged. Beyond a reasonable doubt is a difficult burden to meet. In a civil case the plaintiff must show by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is responsible for any damages. Numerically, a preponderance of the evidence is a showing of a 51% certainty that the defendant is responsible. Beyond a reasonable doubt requires a showing of guilt closer to 100%. This explains why some people are found “not guilty” in a criminal case then found “liable” in a civil case that is based upon the same underlying facts.

Other Civil Versus Criminal Law FAQs

Q: What Is The Difference Between Criminal Law And Civil Law?
A: Civil law involves a private lawsuit between two or more parties. Examples of civil cases include personal injury and business disputes. Criminal matters involve a … More
Q: Can Some Activities Be Both A Criminal Offense And A Civil Offense?
A: Yes. For example, if Dave decides to walk up and slug Matt, Dave may be guilty of battery in a criminal court and he may also be liable to Matt for battery in a civil … More
Q: Is Being Guilty The Same As Being Liable?
A: No. Guilt and innocence are terms used only within a criminal proceeding. Liability or non-liability are terms used only within a civil proceeding.
Q: Can I Be Arrested For The Sole Purpose Of Being Questioned On A Matter?
A: No. The police can request that you accompany them to a police station for questioning but you are not required to go unless you have been arrested for an offense.
Q: Do The Police Have To Wait Until I Have An Attorney Present Before They Question Me?
A: No. It is legal for the police to question you without the presence of an attorney or notifying you of your right to an attorney so long as the questioning is merely … More