Implied Consent Laws
Implied consent is the automatic permission given by motorists to law enforcement to conduct field sobriety tests and chemical tests in the event of a DUI stop. This permission is granted as a condition of obtaining a driver's license and every state has some form of implied consent laws on the books. Generally, an officer does not need a warrant to ask for breath testing.
When suspected of driving while intoxicated, a driver will usually be given the choice between a blood test and a breathalyzer test. There are some states that still rely on urine testing, but this method has proven controversial due to its ambiguity. The purpose of the breathalyzer test is to determine the concentration of alcohol in the blood. However, not every suspected motorist is willing to provide a sample and law enforcement cannot physically force a person to breathe into a tube or submit to blood testing during a traffic stop.
BAC Test Refusal
Chemical tests are refused by more than 20 percent of those stopped for suspicion of driving under the influence, reports the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. It is easier for a DUI attorney to defend a client without having to explain away a test that proves intoxication.
But most states carry a separate administrative penalty for refusing to participate. These punishments vary in severity in accordance with local laws. As such, the breath and blood testing cooperation statistics between states vary just as greatly with as low as 2.4 percent refusal in Delaware to as high as an 81 percent refusal rate in New Hampshire. Even so, a refusal does not guarantee that the defendant will be spared from a DUI conviction. On the contrary: the refusal may be used by the prosecution as evidence of guilt.
Penalties for Refusing Tests
Many times, a driver risks criminal penalties when refusing testing from an officer who initiates a stop due to reasonable suspicion. These penalties may include loss of driving privileges due to license suspension. In fact, many attorneys would advise that refusals are only advantageous when people already have a recent DUI conviction on their driving record.
In California, you can receive a citation for refusing a breathalyzer test, but consenting to a blood test will exempt you from facing that charge. However, some other states are not as forgiving.
In New York, you will receive a 6-month license suspension simply for refusing the test, and you may possibly receive a $500 fine. Massachusetts also imposes a 6-month license suspension and a DWI conviction can possibly mean having your license revoked permanently in certain instances.
In Ohio and Florida, you can lose your license for up to a year. A handful of states even allow police to place an ignition lock on your vehicle when you refuse to consent to a chemical test.
In 2016 the U.S. Supreme Court held in Birchfield v. North Dakota that the refusal to take a blood test after a DUI arrest cannot be considered a separate crime. The Court found that such an imposition would be a violation of the Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures. However, the Court differentiated blood testing from breath testing in its analysis. A warrant is required to ask for a blood sample due to the invasive nature of the needle puncturing the skin and the finite supply of blood that one has available.
Get Legal Help from a DUI Attorney
The potential penalties that can be imposed if a person is convicted of driving under the influence can be significant and can include jail or prison time as well as substantial fines. As a result, those who are facing these types of charges may find it advisable to seek the assistance of a DUI attorney so that a strategy to combat the allegations can be developed.
The information on this page is meant to provide a general overview of the law. The laws in your state and/or city may deviate significantly from those described here. If you have specific questions related to your situation you should speak with a local attorney.
Additional Drunk Driving Articles
- Drunk Driving Defense
- The Crime of Drunk Driving
- Defending a Drunk Driver Hit and Run Charge
- Possible Penalties for Drunk Driving
- The Constitutionality of Sobriety Checkpoints
- What is an Aggravated DUI?
- Overview of Drunk Driving Offenses in the United States
- Drunk Driving & Fourth Amendment Issues
- Breath/Blood Testing in Drunken Driving Cases
- DUI/DWI: The Crime of Drunk Driving
- Drunk Driving Defense Laws in Vermont
- Drunk Driving Defense Law in Rhode Island
- DUI Checkpoints
- DUI Traffic Stop: FAQ
- Should I take police breathalyzer/blood test?
- Reasonable Suspicion for a DUI Stop
- DUI Field Sobriety Tests
- DUI Basics
- Breathalyzer Test FAQ
- Can I Refuse a Breathalyzer?
- Questioning Breathalyzer Calibration
- What are "acts of God" and are they covered by my homeowner's insurance policy?
- What happens when someone is arrested for drunk driving?
State Drunk Driving Articles
- District of Columbia
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York